Demo Discussion
Forum Config Examples Contributions Vulnerabilities
  Discussion forum about ELOG  Not logged in ELOG logo
icon3.gif   Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Dennis Seitz on Wed May 21 21:06:38 2008 
    icon2.gif   Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Stefan Ritt on Mon Jun 2 12:22:48 2008 
       icon2.gif   Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Dennis Seitz on Mon Jun 2 23:30:39 2008 
          icon2.gif   Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Stefan Ritt on Tue Jun 3 12:50:04 2008 
             icon2.gif   Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Dennis Seitz on Thu Jun 5 01:36:07 2008 
                icon2.gif   Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox, posted by Stefan Ritt on Thu Jun 5 08:17:59 2008 Capture.pngCapture.png
Message ID: 65900     Entry time: Thu Jun 5 01:36:07 2008     In reply to: 65899     Reply to this: 65903
Icon: Reply  Author: Dennis Seitz  Author Email: dseitz@cosmology.berkeley.edu 
Category: Request  OS: All  ELOG Version:  
Subject: Re: Make Email All = <list> override Suppress Email checkbox 

 

 

Stefan Ritt wrote:

 

Dennis Seitz wrote:

 

Stefan Ritt wrote:

 

Dennis Seitz wrote:

 I would like to be notified by email of some logbook entries regardless of whether the user has chosen to suppress email or not.

This way I will always be aware of new entries, and users will still have the option of notifying a larger group of other users, or not.

As far as I can tell, presently the Suppress Email checkbox overrides Email All.

 

 

If I make "Email all" override the suppress email checkbox, some uses would complain "I check the supporess box, but my admin still gets email, what am I doing wrong here?". So while this works for you, it will not be desired for everybody. I would have to add another parameter just for this request. Couldn't you instead use the RSS feed functionality? This way you well see all entries, independent of the email notification. You can use special RSS feed readers (your browser and email client probably support this already).

 

Hmm, I see your point, but wouldn't using the RSS feed have the same effect? Or are you saying the users just wouldn't know about it, so they wouldn't complain? 

I haven't explored the RSS feed options yet. I'll study them.

 

The RSS feed you have to "pull" actively with a client (which of course can be periodically in an automatic way). So no pull, no notification, happy users

 

Hmm. Is there some way to set up a private RSS feed for me only?

If not, I would humbly ask that you add an option. I don't want to generate unnecessary email to users, but I need to always be notified for some logbooks. I'm responsible for some hardware on our project and I want to know any time someone reports a problem. The best solution is to still let users decide whether they want to subscribe to logbooks, and whether entry notification should be suppressed or not, but also have an admin override privilege. There could be a disclaimer "admin is automatically notified of all entries" at the top of the edit page.

If this can be done with a private RSS feed to me only, then that's fine. I still don't use or understand RSS feeds very well, sorry. I'd rather all users did not have the option to be alerted to every new entry, when email suppression is enabled. That would be contradictory, I think.

 Thanks for listening!

 

ELOG V3.1.5-fe60aaf