Hello,

I just upgraded to elog 2.7.5 from 2.6.4 on my Debian system. Here is some feedback:

1) "make" fails if libssl-dev package is not installed. Documentation does not mention SSL library requirements.

2) /etc/init.d/elogd: line 10: /etc/rc.d/init.d/functions: No such file or directory (I fixed this by commenting
out that line).

3) Starting elogd: /etc/init.d/elogd: line 34: echo_success: command not found (Fixed by search/replace "echo_"
to "echo ").


Hope this helps.

George.

> 1) "make" fails if libssl-dev package is not installed. Documentation does not mention SSL library requirements.

I added a note to the documentation, thank you.

> 2) /etc/init.d/elogd: line 10: /etc/rc.d/init.d/functions: No such file or directory (I fixed this by commenting
> out that line).
> 
> 3) Starting elogd: /etc/init.d/elogd: line 34: echo_success: command not found (Fixed by search/replace "echo_"
> to "echo ").

The elogd (or elogd.init in the distribution) is written for RedHat based systems where echo_success gives the 
typical output with a green [OK] at the end of the line. For Debian, there is (was) in principle a Debian package 
which has it's own startup script. Since the package maintainer is not active any more (I guess), the Debian 
updates are heavily old. Once elog gets managed inside Debian again, that should get better again, but until then 
one has to follow 2) and 3) from above. If I would remove it, the Scientific Linux users would complain. 

 Just run it inside gdb. When it crashes, you will see a segment violation and you will end up at the debugger prompt. Then do a "bt" to see the stack dump. From that I can guess where the problem happens.

> elogd is crashing with a segv when I try to create a new logbook by clicking the "Create new logbook" button
> with an existing logbook selected in the dropdown list as a template. I've attached my config file for
> reference. As a specific example, I'm logged in as the admin user, viewing logbook "1248", which has no entries,
> and I click "Config" -> "Change config file" -> "Create new logbook", Select "1248" from dropdown list, enter
> "1250" for the new logbook name, and click "Create new logbook".
> 
> The server crashes, and my web browser has the following as the (incorrect) URL it's trying to load:
> (Incorrect because the "/ATLAS" shouldn't be there.)
> 
> https://localhost:8080/ATLAS/1250/?cmd=Config
> 
> Nevertheless, the config file and logbook directory are properly modified for the new logbook, and on restarting
> the server, everything is fine.
> 
> Oh, just noticed that if I manually enter the URL:
> 
> https://localhost:8080/ATLAS/1250/
> 
> or actually, any text in place of the "1250", it also crashes the elogd process. So, perhaps there are two bugs?
> 
> (1) Incorrect URL being given to the web client after logbook creation
> (2) Requesting any incorrect URL of this form crashes elogd

This problems have been fixed in SVN revision 2135.

> The elogd (or elogd.init in the distribution) is written for RedHat based systems where echo_success gives the 
> typical output with a green [OK] at the end of the line. For Debian, there is (was) in principle a Debian package 
> which has it's own startup script. Since the package maintainer is not active any more (I guess), the Debian 
> updates are heavily old. Once elog gets managed inside Debian again, that should get better again, but until then 
> one has to follow 2) and 3) from above. If I would remove it, the Scientific Linux users would complain. 

That makes sense. Might be worth adding a short Debian section to the installation instructions page?

FYI, Elog is no longer in Debian as of 2008-05-12.


Thanks,

George.

When submitting entries via the elog client, I find that I can set arbitrary values for attributes that are supposedly "preset" and "locked".

As an example, I have in my elogd.cfg file:

[global]

...

Group Operations = Accelerator

Top group ATLAS = Operations

...

[global ATLAS]

Attributes = Experiment, Author, Author Email, Category, Subject
Required Attributes = Category, Subject
Options Category = Routine entry, Shift summary, Problem, Fix, Question, Info, Other
Extendable Options = Category

Preset Experiment =
Preset Author = $long_name
Preset Author Email = $user_email
Locked Attributes = Experiment, Author, Author Email

...

[Accelerator]
Attributes = Author, Author Email, Category, Subject
Options Category = Routine entry, Shift summary, Problem, Fix, Question, Info, Other

...

This works as intended with a web client (firefox). The Author and Author Email attributes are preset and unchangeable.

However, if I use the elog client, as in:

elog -v -h my.apache-proxy.server -d elog -l Accelerator -p 443 -s -u johndoe xxxxx -a Category=LN -a Subject=Test -a Author=IDoNotExist -n 1 -m entry.txt 
(johndoe is an existing user)

 

The entry is created with "IDoNotExist" as the Author name, instead of the correct name for the user johndoe,
and the Author Email attribute is blank.

Is there a way to enforce preset and locked attributes in the elogd server? (As a client could connect
with any arbitrary software, not just elog.)

If I add this statement to a logbook config file:

Show attachments = 0

When viewing and individual entry, attached images are not displayed, which is as intended, but the links Show/Hide and Show All/Hide All are still displayed although they do nothing when clicked except switch between Show and Hide. Clicking on an image opens it in a separate window.

Could you make show/hide and show/hide all work? This way, by default the images are not displayed, but the default could be overridden on a case by case basis as desired, and the images displayed inline in the same window with the entry. 

Thanks!

elogd continues to run after a SIGHUP. If a second SIGHUP is received the daemon terminates.
This was observed on Solaris 10 (SPARC).
The documentation states that elogd should re-read configuration after receiving SIGHUP.