Demo Discussion
Forum Config Examples Contributions Vulnerabilities
  Discussion forum about ELOG, Page 212 of 801  Not logged in ELOG logo
ID Date Icon Author Author Email Category OS ELOG Versiondown Subject
  69544   Tue Jul 19 11:17:44 2022 Reply Tamas Galtgal@km3net.deQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

Thanks for the quick reply! Sorry, I forgot to paste the "global" part of the config, I have that URL already set:

[global]
;Main Settings
;=============
Usr = elog
Grp = elog
port = 8080
SSL = 0
URL = https://elog.test.km3net.de
Title image = <img border=0 src="KM3NeT_logo.png" alt="KM3NeT logo" height="35px">
;SMTP host = smtp.fau.de
Display mode = summary
Thumbnail size = 500>
List Menu text = clock.html
Menu text = clock.html

Stefan Ritt wrote:

Probably you need a setting

URL = https://elog.test.km3net.de

or so in your elogd.cfg file.

Stefan

 

  69545   Tue Jul 19 11:24:36 2022 Reply Tamas Galtgal@km3net.deQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

I also tried the default configuration (example config) and it that works behind the load balancer. So I guess it's related to the password-page, which causes this redirect loop? Our logbooks are all password protected, so when a logbook URL is clicked, it should first present the login-form, and that's where it chokes.

  69546   Tue Jul 19 11:40:59 2022 Reply Stefan Rittstefan.ritt@psi.chQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

Yeah, after you enter a password, elog redirects to what it finds in "URL". You can trace that by opening "development tools" in Google Chrome, go to "network" and watch packets going back and forth. I never worked with the load balancer, but maybe you need a different "URL" containing a '/' at the end?

Tamas Gal wrote:

I also tried the default configuration (example config) and it that works behind the load balancer. So I guess it's related to the password-page, which causes this redirect loop? Our logbooks are all password protected, so when a logbook URL is clicked, it should first present the login-form, and that's where it chokes.

 

  69547   Tue Jul 19 12:36:04 2022 Reply Tamas Galtgal@km3net.deQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

My problem is that I don't even reach the page where I can enter a password. If you go to https://elog.test.km3net.de and click on a logbook, you'll see that it immediately goes into a redirect loop. I already logged the routing but there is nothing else...

Stefan Ritt wrote:

Yeah, after you enter a password, elog redirects to what it finds in "URL". You can trace that by opening "development tools" in Google Chrome, go to "network" and watch packets going back and forth. I never worked with the load balancer, but maybe you need a different "URL" containing a '/' at the end?

Tamas Gal wrote:

I also tried the default configuration (example config) and it that works behind the load balancer. So I guess it's related to the password-page, which causes this redirect loop? Our logbooks are all password protected, so when a logbook URL is clicked, it should first present the login-form, and that's where it chokes.

 

 

  69548   Tue Jul 19 12:38:12 2022 Reply Tamas Galtgal@km3net.deQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

Attached is the log, where you can see that `Operations+IT` redirects to `Operations+IT/` and that redirects to `Operations+IT` again, which then goes to `elog.test.km3net.de` and `Operations+IT` again etc. etc.

EDIT: I  use the very same load balancer confugration for dozens of other services incl. Apache, Nginx, GitLab, Mattermost, RocketChat etc. and all work fine. As written before, also the "example" logbook works (without password protection).

I also tried `/` at the end of the URL but it has no effect.

I am pretty clueless currently...

Attachment 1: Screenshot_2022-07-19_at_12.37.55.png
Screenshot_2022-07-19_at_12.37.55.png
  69549   Tue Jul 19 12:48:42 2022 Reply Stefan Rittstefan.ritt@psi.chQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

Yes I see the redirects. You say with the example logbook it works, right? Is it the password protection which triggers the problem or anything else? Does it work if you take out the password protection? The key is to identify which setting in your config file triggers the problem, so you can bracket the problem down between the example logbook and your logbook definition.

  69550   Tue Jul 19 12:57:37 2022 Reply Tamas Galtgal@km3net.deQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

Yes, I used the empty `passwd` file from example. When I then click on one of the logbooks, I get to the page where I can register a user (see attached screenshot). After clickin on "Save" for the user registration, I again get the redirect error. Once there is a registered user (i.e. a non-empty password file) the redirect issue is persistent. Any idea where the problem might be? I just emptied the password file again, so you can have a one-shot, if you like.

Btw. I have SSL termination in the load balancer, so ELOG does not need to do any SSL related things (the swarm is in a locally isolated network, so all internal communication between the load balancer and the swarm machines are safe). Maybe that's the issue? On the other hand, the main page loads fine and uses SSL termination too, so I don't know, maybe there is logic behind the authentication which collides with the SSL termination.

Stefan Ritt wrote:

Yes I see the redirects. You say with the example logbook it works, right? Is it the password protection which triggers the problem or anything else? Does it work if you take out the password protection? The key is to identify which setting in your config file triggers the problem, so you can bracket the problem down between the example logbook and your logbook definition.

 

Attachment 1: Screenshot_2022-07-19_at_13.02.19.png
Screenshot_2022-07-19_at_13.02.19.png
  Draft   Fri Jan 20 14:08:25 2023 Question Tamas Galhe iQuestionLinux3.1.3Re: Too many redirects when running behind load balancer?

The issue is still present and now it's quite urgent to move this last service into the Swarm. Does anyone maybe have an idea what's wrong? To sum up: if there is a non-empty password file, the login page chokes in an infinite loop of redirects. I am using the same HAProxy load balancer configuration as for all the other services (running Apache, NGINX, GitLab, XWiki, etc.):

backend be_elog.km3net.de
    mode http

    option forwardfor except 127.0.0.1
    http-request add-header X-Forwarded-Proto https if { ssl_fc }

    server-template km3net-elog- 1 km3net-elog_elog:8080 check resolvers docker init-addr libc,none

Tamas Gal wrote:

Yes, I used the empty `passwd` file from example. When I then click on one of the logbooks, I get to the page where I can register a user (see attached screenshot). After clickin on "Save" for the user registration, I again get the redirect error. Once there is a registered user (i.e. a non-empty password file) the redirect issue is persistent. Any idea where the problem might be? I just emptied the password file again, so you can have a one-shot, if you like.

Btw. I have SSL termination in the load balancer, so ELOG does not need to do any SSL related things (the swarm is in a locally isolated network, so all internal communication between the load balancer and the swarm machines are safe). Maybe that's the issue? On the other hand, the main page loads fine and uses SSL termination too, so I don't know, maybe there is logic behind the authentication which collides with the SSL termination.

Stefan Ritt wrote:

Yes I see the redirects. You say with the example logbook it works, right? Is it the password protection which triggers the problem or anything else? Does it work if you take out the password protection? The key is to identify which setting in your config file triggers the problem, so you can bracket the problem down between the example logbook and your logbook definition.

 

 

ELOG V3.1.5-3fb85fa6